Us-versus-them positioning | BMD Marketing Library
Home Library Us-versus-them positioning
Seed

Seed Us-versus-them positioning

us-versus-them

Define

The buyer is invited into a side. The product is what we use. The named other is what we refuse.

Mechanism

Identity contrast. Choosing the offer is choosing a group. The out-group does as much work as the claim.

Verdict

The category is crowded and the buyer wants to signal affiliation, craft, or values.

Don't

The market is small, the attack becomes the whole brand, or the them is a person rather than a stance.

Copy skeleton

Most [CATEGORY] does [THEM].

We do [US] because [VALUE].

[PROOF of the difference]

[ASK: join this side]

Gulf note

Contrast the method, not the people. In the Gulf a named rival can close a room. Name the default we refuse: the agency habit, the vanity metric, the imported template.

All 64 patterns

Rights-cleared examples

Life-line of the nation" poster

Life-line of the nation" poster

commons.wikimedia.org public-domain-us
Make Every Minute Count For Pershing. United States Shipping Board Merchant Fleet Corporation" poster

Make Every Minute Count For Pershing. United States Shipping Board Merchant Fleet Corporation" poster

commons.wikimedia.org public-domain-us
She's a WOW" poster

She's a WOW" poster

commons.wikimedia.org public-domain-us
100 Percent Production - Axis trouble. Keep the bums on the Double!" poster

100 Percent Production - Axis trouble. Keep the bums on the Double!" poster

commons.wikimedia.org public-domain-us
100 octane puts our boys on top!" poster

100 octane puts our boys on top!" poster

commons.wikimedia.org public-domain-us
America is the loser too - when avoidable accidents stop production. The U.S. army says - 'Make haste safely" poster

America is the loser too - when avoidable accidents stop production. The U.S. army says - 'Make haste safely" poster

commons.wikimedia.org public-domain-us
America's fishing fleet and men...A assects to victory" poster

America's fishing fleet and men...A assects to victory" poster

commons.wikimedia.org public-domain-us
Americas answer! Production" poster

Americas answer! Production" poster

commons.wikimedia.org public-domain-us
An ostrich only thinks he 'covers up" poster

An ostrich only thinks he 'covers up" poster

commons.wikimedia.org public-domain-us
And if our lines should form, then break' (a U.S. Marine)" poster

And if our lines should form, then break' (a U.S. Marine)" poster

commons.wikimedia.org public-domain-us
Answer Honestly" poster

Answer Honestly" poster

commons.wikimedia.org public-domain-us
Beat these Three Knaves with your production 'Aces" poster

Beat these Three Knaves with your production 'Aces" poster

commons.wikimedia.org public-domain-us

See all 81 in the Ads gallery