HomeLibraryAdsUs-versus-them positioning
Library ad

Us-versus-them positioning

Bile Bean Manufacturing Co. Nature's Road to Health booklet

wellcomecollection.orgarchive-open-access

The pattern

This still is filed under Us-versus-them positioning.

Define

The buyer is invited into a side. The product is what we use. The named other is what we refuse.

Mechanism

Identity contrast. Choosing the offer is choosing a group. The out-group does as much work as the claim.

Verdict

The category is crowded

Read the pattern

Why it works

It opens by splitting the reader's options in two, 'One way is right, and the other is wrong': drugs on one side, Nature on the other, and the cover's winding country road puts Bile Beans on the right one. Mrs. Crumplin's story then does the persuading, because Bile Beans came only after 'numerous so-called cures' had failed her, and two doctors' certificates and a free sample box take away the last risk.

The big idea

Two ways to get well: rush to drugs that often do more harm than good, or take Nature's road, where Bile Beans are the vegetable remedy.

The offer

A free sample box of Bile Beans and a book on liver and digestive ailments, for your name, address, a penny stamp and the coupon. A Biloscope picture novelty comes post free for seven stamps.

The proof

Testimonials from Mrs. Crumplin of Portsmouth, cured after 'numerous so-called cures' failed, Mrs. Strafford and railway ganger Joseph Atwell, plus certificates from two doctors, C. H. Bennett and J. H. Hart.

Lines from the ad

NATURE'S ROAD TO HEALTH
One way is right, and the other is wrong.
The wrong way is to fly to drugs, which, in many cases, do more harm than good.

Steal this when

Your buyers have already tried the usual fixes, and you can frame your product as the other road and let one named customer who tried both tell the story.

The emotion

Written to Disappointment. It makes the Say move.

Mrs. Crumplin's story starts where 'numerous so-called cures' had failed her, and a free sample box plus two doctors' certificates let a reader who has been let down test the claim first.

All ads

Library updates

If this library is useful, leave an email

We send new patterns, ads, and notes when we add them. Name and phone are optional.

Optional
Optional