HomeLibraryAdsUs-versus-them positioning
Library ad

Us-versus-them positioning

Perrier sparkling water ad, al-Musawwar 1931

digitalcollections.aucegypt.edupublic-domain (university archive statement)Country: EgyptCollection: al-Musawwar

American University in Cairo, Rare Books and Special Collections Library. al-Musawwar. RBSCL believes this item is in the public domain.

The pattern

This still is filed under Us-versus-them positioning.

Define

The buyer is invited into a side. The product is what we use. The named other is what we refuse.

Mechanism

Identity contrast. Choosing the offer is choosing a group. The out-group does as much work as the claim.

Verdict

The category is crowded

Read the pattern

Why it works

The headline splits the shelf in two: factory soda on one side, Perrier on the other, and the reader is asked to pick a side before any benefit is named. The body gives the reason in one contrast: the gas in artificial water is dead, the spring gas in Perrier is alive because nature made it. Only then come the benefits, light, digestible and good for the gut, which now read as consequences of that difference.

The big idea

Sparkling water comes in two kinds: factory soda made with dead carbonic gas, and Perrier, whose spring gas is alive because nature made it.

The offer

Perrier natural sparkling water from the spring: light, digestible, refreshing to the chest and helpful to the bowels.

Lines from the ad

الفرق عظيم بين المياه الغازية الاصطناعية ومياه بريه

There is a great difference between artificial sparkling water and Perrier water

فغاز الكاربونيك الذي يستعمل لتحضير المياه الغازية الاصطناعية هو جوهر ميت

The carbonic gas used to make artificial sparkling water is a dead substance

Le Champagne des Eaux de Table

Steal this when

A natural or original product competes with cheaper imitations and needs the buyer to see the category as two camps.

The emotion

Written to Confusion. It makes the Say move.

It gives the shopper one plain test for every sparkling water on the shelf: was the gas made in a factory, or does it come from the spring, as Perrier's does.

All ads

Library updates

If this library is useful, leave an email

We send new patterns, ads, and notes when we add them. Name and phone are optional.

Optional
Optional